I have been thinking about the comments that have been made to me about posting on a particular topic.
I have a cause that I believe in with all of my heart and soul, and moving to Idaho made that reality more pronounced because of legal situations that prevent me from getting the medication that I need, and that could have helped to of my family members who have died from cancer.
I have heard many times, I mean many many many times from a few select individuals on this site how bad my conversations are for this site, and how it is so horrible that they have to read my topics (btw- There is no requirement to read this)
So I have been scouting out what it takes to make a good blog.
The points illustrated in this blog post seem to be a common consensus. But as to not alarm the link police, I will only use one link here.
http://www.43folders.com/2008/08/19/good-blogs
Point 1.
Good blogs have a voice. Who wrote this? What is their name? What can I figure out about who they are that they have never overtly told me? What’s their personality like and what do they have to contribute — even when it’s “just” curation. What tics and foibles fascinate make me about this blog and the person who makes it? Most importantly: what obsesses this person?
I complete agree with this point entirely, which is why the anonymous posters (even the ones who use their first names) are so inconsiquential to me. The less identity you reveal, the less your comments mean to me. But this is the same anywhere. If you are going to have an opinion, and no identity your opinion isn’t worth much anywhere.
Point 2.
Good blogs reflect focused obsessions. People start real blogs because they think about something a lot. Maybe even five things. But, their brain so overflows with curiosity about a family of topics that they can’t stop reading and writing about it. They make and consume smart forebrain porn. So: where do this person’s obsessions take them?
Again, this is something that I completely agree with. So many people here are so offended by my obession with marijuana legalization. But that’s the point, this is a topic very close to my heart and a very urgent need in my life. I am truly obessed. But in the realm of interesting topics, it’s obvious that my obession was not only effective for my own cause, but it generated a lot of activity on this message board. Inconsiquential topics like “Barry’s fry house is changing locations” is really not a hot topic. Which would explain why most of the posts in this message board get little if any response.
Point 3.
Good blogs are the product of “
AttentiontimesInterest.” A blog shows me where someone’s attention tends to go. Then, on some level, they encourage me to follow the evolution of their interest through a day or a year. There’s a story here. Ethical “via” links make it easy for me to follow their specific trail of attention, then join them for a walk made out of words.
This is key for me. A one time wam bam thank you mam isn’t the way I blog. If I am truly concerned about a topic I make sure that is expressed in my words. As this point makes, it is necessary to provide links, and resources so that someone can follow the full range of the story being told, they can follow the train of thought of the person posting it if they desire to.
Point 4.
Good blog posts are made of paragraphs. Blog posts are written, not defecated. They show some level of craft, thinking, and continuity beyond the word count mandated by the Owner of Your Plantation. If a blog has fixed limits on post minimums and maximums? It’s not a blog: it’s a website that hires writers. Which is fine. But, it’s not really a blog.
I agree with this. The little posts that I see on blogs where someone posts a few lines of thought, and drops the conversation isn’t a blog, it’s a brain-fart IMHO. Paragraphs, Refernces, and Pictures are very important for a good blog post, again in my opinion.
Point 5.
Good “non-post” blogs have style and curation. Some of the best blogs use unusual formats, employ only photos and video, or utilize the list format to artistic effect. I regret there are not more blogs that see format as the container for creativity — rather than an excuse to write less or link without context more.
How can I not agree with this, I live by these words.
Point 6.
Good blogs are weird. Blogs make fart noises and occasionally vex readers with the degree to which the blogger’s obsession will inevitably diverge from the reader’s. If this isn’t happening every few weeks, the blogger is either bored, half-assing, or taking new medication.
Enough said here. I couldn’t agree more. This is probably the best point of the entire article.
Point 7.
Good blogs make you want to start your own blog. At some point, everyone wants to kill the Buddha and make their own obsessions the focus. This is good. It means you care.
I started ‘blogging’ when I was 13 and I had a Commodore 64, and a 300 baud modem kit that I got from a buddy and we soldered things together, and got on “Fidonet” and a bunch of local bulletin boards. By the time I was 15, I was helping my buddy debug his message board built on an old 386 on a Unix platform, it was a gaming and message platform called “Dark Fortress”. I was hooked. After a few years I worked on other small platforms such as an Amiga server called “Psionic Blue” and posted hundreds of posts a week. I eventually dropped out of highschool and taught myself how to program in multiple languages.. (I went back later and continued on to college). But ‘blogging’ or posting on message boards inspired this in me. The message boards that I went to when I was a kid were full of progressive and thoughtful people that challenged me to my core. Now I own 33 domains, and I keep collecting more and more. What can I say, Im obessed. OCD? For blogging, definately. But I think I also like the programming, and graphic design part of it too. It’s like being a painter that can’t stop painting I guess.
Point 8.
Good blogs try. I’ve come to believe that creative life in the first-world comes down to those who try just a little bit harder. Then, there’s the other 98%. They’re still eating the free continental breakfast over at FriendFeed. A good blog is written by a blogger who thinks longer, works harder, and obsesses more. Ultimately, a good blogger tries. That’s why “good” is getting rare.
I have to agree with this. I see some of the best posters on this blog have their own blog, or radio show, or whatever. It’s obvious that there is a dedication, a passion, a love for writing and inspiring others. Those that come only to post one liners, or who come to irritate someone else show no passion, no life, no inspiration. I prefer those who are wierd, corky, and passionate as opposed to the anonymous one liners that exist out there.
Point 9.
Good blogs know when to break their own rules.
He makes a good point here, and he made a list that is linked on his original post. Read it if you’re curious.
In summary, I see that this site is truly waning in traffic right now, and I can only think of how uninspiring the posts are that are getting posted (not all, but most).. It seems like for a few weeks, people were ONLY posting to drown out posts that they didn’t like to see. They would post a few lines or a single paragraph and then finish never to come back to that post again. Dead fish anyone?
Im sure that there are many people who would like to say something here but probably are refraining from speaking up, because they don’t want to deal with all of the drama. Why can’t some people post constructively? It seems like they just can’t do it.
Anyway, that is my point of view. What do you think makes a good blog?

Popularity: 8%
Related posts:



{ 18 comments… read them below or add one }
I don’t think it’s the quality of your arguments that were ever in question slu. You seem to be very knowledgeable on your subject, probably more than anyone else that frequents this site.
It was never a question of quality, just quantity. Sometimes less is more, IMHO.
Thanks Alice, but what do you think makes a good blog?
Here is some other opinions about my points in this message. From this blog, check out the “anonymous” blog.
http://www.idahofallstoday.com/2007/03/14/into-the-woods-of-anonymous-speech/#comment-31631
It’s relevant.
If I am actively commenting on a blog, the blog that I’m actively commenting on is good.
Good is relative, and you’re not the judge of good.
But there are some things that are “detrimental” to a blog no?
I was only stating my opinion about “what makes a good blog”… I had some people try to tell me that this blog was all of the sudden not-so-good. I just wanted people to define what the feel makes a good blog.
Great, have you made your own blog? You can manage that at the same time as commenting etc here. Just a thought.
PS I don’t state my whole name because I don’t want “crazies” stalking me and my children. I have an unusual easy to stalk last name. Honestly, if that effects my credibility that’s ok, because my families safety is more important to me than people I don’t know thinking I’m credible. It’s all in what you deam more important to you.
PS I don’t post because I know I’m not a good writer. Period. I suck at it and I know it. I think others are much more concise in their deliveries and frankly that intimidates me.
Detrimental in terms of traffic. If you’re talking traffic, it’s a different story.
Otherwise, detrimental is relative too.
Good Blog = a blog where people can have productive discussion.
Productive can be changing peoples minds or simply creating good humor. It depends on the environment and what is appropriate.
Oh, and usually it’s good to be interested in that discussion, because if your not interested in the discussion it’s not a “good” blog for you.
I think Marcus has a point in saying that it is all relative.
Great points by Alice, Marcus & April. There’s not much more I can add.
My recommendation for a good blog : Delete it. About 99.9% of them are pure garbage. They spread hate and distrust, they’re misinformed, ignorant, and poorly-conceived. Stop blogging, and get outside and enjoy life.
Yet you continue to post on them Jeremy. Alrightythen. That made sense.
Like everything else in life, don’t take blogging so seriously. Especially to the point where you’re letting people on the other end raise your blood pressure. Take it the same way you should take television and the nightly news, as a form of entertainment. Because really folks, that’s all it is. If you find yourself getting your feelings hurt over somebody elses comments, yeah, it’s time to take a break and find a new form of entertainment.
I was totally waiting for someone to say just that, CR67. Funny, it only took something like 5 minutes. Oh, the internet.
I do what I can.
Goof blogs are very hard work, and must be kept up on a regular basis even if it means getting up early or staying up late. Good blogs take time. There is no such thing as add water and microwave to make a good blog.
Thanks for the constructive conversation. It’s good to hear people’s point of view. I have gotten a lot of feedback about traffic on this website. To me it seems like when people are complaining and whining the traffic declines. When people are actively posting constructive conversation, the traffic picks up. Just my point of view. But it seems like it’s all speculation. Joe Eagle seems like the person who should be most concerned about traffic, and he would be the person to know.
Just because people don’t post (maybe because they don’t want to get belittled or dramatized), doesn’t mean that traffic is declining.
@April, “Great, have you made your own blog? You can manage that at the same time as commenting etc here. Just a thought. ”
I have 5 blogs that I own, and I moderate or help out on a few others. I just started a internet radio station less than a week ago also. I also have a bunch of other websites, but I don’t pay a lot of attention to them.
I like to discuss a lot of different topics. One of my blogs is a religion blog, one of my blogs is for Utah news/politics/etc (we used to live in Utah), another one of them is dedicated to creating/improving/modifying different types of technology… And then of course I own http://www.xCannabis.com which is getting the most attention from me right now. I started that blog about 6 months ago.
Then I have my business and project websites.
But I like getting different opinions, and different topics, and I like to participate in my local community. So I go to about 10 blogs that I don’t own and I blog about a variety of different topics.
I like this blog a lot. There are a few (very few) good posters here, and even if they disagree with me, I do enjoy reading what they have to say, and getting their opinions.
BTW- April, thanks for being open and expressing your opinion on the infant potty training blog post. Constructive conversation like that is what this is all about.
Even though you’re partially anonymous, you don’t take the “wam bam thank you mam” route of posting a flame or a one liner. You actually put your heart into it and I can tell.
Those who have nothing but antagonizing and nonconstructive conversation and who are also anonymous, I call them gnats because of how insignificant their thoughts are. bzzzzz is what it looks like to me.
Anyway, thanks for your response April!
The key to a good blog?
I started to comment on this thread, but clicked away to work on my blog because that’s where my main interest lies. I think that’s one of the things that makes for a good blog. One that’s published by a person who’s drawn to work on it rather to post on a message board.
I think a good blog is an accurate personal expression of it’s owner. If a person is going to blog well, he should be familiar enough with himself to know his passions, and he should be fearless enough to publish the things he’s passionate about in as many writing styles as he’s able to utilize.
Videos add wonderful flavor to a blog, I love publishing tunes that people in my age group know, there’s never enough ZZ Top or Grateful Dead on the web. They provide a good break from all the drivel that every blog in the universe usually spews. Mine included.
Mix news items with fictional short stories, and especially include spur of the moment pieces that pop into your head and demand to be written, even if you have to outline them on the back of a napkin at a coffee shop.
Comments aren’t an indication of a good blog, in many cases they’re an indication of a message board or a circle of friends staying in touch. Your stats plugin will tell you about how good your blog is with your visitor load and page views.
A good blog is written by the guy that clicks the site admin button, that, goes looking for plugins and widgets, and pretty much always has an itch to click the post new page link.
“comments aren’t an indication of a good blog”
That’s kind of what I was thinking. I don’t think this would even really be considered a “blog”. I think this is a message board. That’s a totally different animal. A blog is your baby, a message board is more an exchange of ideas with others and once it leaves your hands, outside of moderation, it has a life of it’s own.
So I guess the question would be, “what makes a good message board and good message board participants?”.