Four-day school weeks in Idaho Falls?
If you're new here, you may want to subscribe to the newsletter or RSS feed. Thanks for visiting!
The Post Register reported Boundary County is reaping great rewards since switching to a four-day week. Fridays are off, and are a time many students engage in positive extracurricular activities.
Many corporations have allowed four-day work weeks. Some Idaho Falls businesses offer four-hour workweeks.
Should Idaho Falls and/or Bonneville School Districts switch to four-day weeks? What are the benefits?
If you enjoyed this post, please consider to leave a comment or subscribe to the feed and get future articles delivered to your feed reader.
Comments
I taught school in Shelley the year they did the four day school week. It was difficult for me as a teacher, because you were reteaching on Monday after a long weekend. The kids liked it so much that they actually had a sit in in the gym to protest having to go to school on a Friday because of taking too many snow days. I wouldn’t recommend it for anyone.
I work a four-day work week, and rather enjoy it. It does make for long hours — ten hours of work a day, sandwiched by four hours on the bus.
A four-day work week would be murder on teachers. My wife used to teach high school English, yearbook and broadcasting. She quit after four years because she was tired of her regular, 14 to 16 hour days, five days a week, and sometimes six. Reducing the days kids are at school won’t reduce that — mostly unpaid — teacher workload.
Besides, I’d be very worried if my school district initiated a four-day week, for the sake of my kids. I’ve got a first-grader and a pre-schooler. I don’t like the idea of my kids having to spend more time a day at school. They need balance in their lives just like the rest of us.
Now, if for high school students, my district wanted a four-day week, I’d be more receptive. However, ask that high school kid who has an after-school job if a four-day week is a good idea. And the money-saving thing isn’t all that it’s cracked up to be. I read in the Christian Science Monitor that the district in Orofino, Idaho, tried the four-day work week, thinking they’d save $150,000 on average a year in transportation costs. Their average savings, since making the switch in 2004? $12,000 a year. What we need to do in school is simply require more of the students. My wife got burned out on teaching because she got tired of all the parents coming to her, screaming about their little angel failing this class and that class, and not believing her when she said their kid is failing because they’re not doing the required work. And then she had administrators coming in with the parents, saying, in effect, hey, pass this guy’s kid or he won’t talk to me neighborly any more. Our education system — particularly some kids and their parents — needs a bigger kick in the pants than a four-day week will deliver. And this isn’t something that can be fixed with money, either. We need to get kids and parents back in school together to learn a little responsibility. When I was failing, when my wife was failing, our parents didn’t go screaming to the teacher. We got hollered at and got figuratively kicked in the butt to improve. And that’s what we’ll do with our kids.
The issues both for and against four-day school weeks are valid.
I think a condensed week could help teach our students to get into a longer work groove and produce more work, rather than being interrupted right when they get into the groove.
I agree with you on balance, but that balance can also be achieved with longer weekends of free time.
The teacher workload is an issue they’d need to work out. I’ve taught also, and I would’ve traded my every-other-daily planning period for a half-day on Friday morning where I could work uninterrupted to plan for the next week. But everyone works differently.
What other concerns do you have with a four day school week or even four day work weeks?
Today’s Post Register reports Clark County is also switching to four-day school weeks. They cite the goal of increasing academic achievements as their primary reason.
They will extend each day 45 minutes (though that only makes up 3 hours from Friday, so I don’t know how that works out).
They report overwhelming public support for this move.
The PR also reported Challis School District changed to 4-day weeks in 2003, and they love it. They report higher test scores and happy parents.
The strange anomaly for 4-day school weeks has been Shelley school district, where they tried it and encountered increased academic success, but the parents hated it and torpedoed the idea. Who knows what they’re doing in Shelley, anyways?
What do you think of four-day school weeks for Idaho Falls-area schools?
It’s my understanding that another big reason for switching to 4 days a week is cost. For example, buses would run less, using less fuel, requiring less maintenence, and drivers would work less hours. (One Clark County driver stated on the channel 3 story that her salary will drop by about 200 a month)
In addition, there would be lower costs for electricity, maintenence, and heat of the buildings in the district. Also, student athletes would miss less classwork because they could schedule games on Fridays, when there are no classes.
It is true that some parents would be opposed to it, and it could cause problems with child supervision since the 5 day work week is pretty much the standard in the U.S. Personally, I don’t see a problem with it… Besides, money not spent on buses, heat, or electricity could be better spent on the educations of our kids, right?
The demographics of most residents of Shelley with kids in school, compared to those in Clark County or Challis, I would expect to be very different.
Shelley, for all intent and purposes is a suburb of Idaho Falls. Even the statistical metro numbers don’t include Shelley in terms of that measure of the census, all other measure of the “service area” and population for the Idaho Falls area do include Shelley. So essentially, Shelley residents are part of the 250,000-300,000 in the I.F. Service area, and just outside the 116,000 person metro area.
Clark County and Challis are far more rural. The High School age kids can’t be at the mall in 10 minutes, like the kids living in Taylor or east of Shelley (who attend Shelley schools) can.
Economic opportunities are limited in Clark County and Challis. There aren’t as many even part-time jobs for a spouse or school age kids to work.
So in many ways, I don’t see how what works for a very rural district can be directly compared with a much larger district that is now 5 miles south of a MMSA, Idaho Falls.
Also, in Idaho with the teacher shortage (which is not only a problem in Idaho), if I recall correctly, it was easier to recruit teachers to teach school with a 4 day work week in these rural areas. Then, if they wanted to leave for the weekend, they had some time away.
Personally, I wonder what kids get accomplished in school on Fridays anyway. Yah, back when the dinasours roamed, many of us actually attended school 5 days/week, myself included.
The more I deal with many school districts in a four state area, the more I question what kids actually learn in school these days.
in the rural Oregon community where my family resides we have a 4 day school week. The kids love it and so do most of the parents. I get 3 days with my kids every weekend to do things and if i want 5 days I just pull them out for thursday and monday and can take a nice trip. They do attend 50 minutes longer than they did in IF but that gives my wife more time without the kids during the week to get her stuff done. The teachers love the half day on Friday with or without kids. Friday school is optional for some kids and manatory if they have a D or F in any class and it is the parents responsibility to get them there and pick them up. All the more reson to make sure your child is doing his/her work and not falling behind. the annual savings to our school district is just over $230k. (saleries and benifits for almost 4 teachers) with the cost of fuel rising it is a little more each year. Sports are scheduled for Friday when possible. Most of our grounds maintenance is done by students working on fridays instead of hireing a full time person to do the job and having to pay full benefits. $8.00 per hour for a highschool kid only working on fridays is prety good around here and there is no shortage of applicants. My kids only complaint is they have about 2 hours of homework each weekend. (includeing one hour of reading). I don’t feel a bit sorry for them. I love the 4 day schoolweek and would strongly encourage it.
Leave Your Comment
Our Community's Comment Guidelines:- Please stay polite and on topic.
- Your email will never be published.
- No profanity or euphemisms for profanity.
- No personal attacks, name-calls, put-downs, or baiting other guests, races, genders, or religions.
- Express opinions, facts, logic, and reasoning; just don’t argue for argument’s sake.
- No commercial links (unless absolutely relevant to the discussion) and no religious proselytizing.
- No religious discussions (for or against). Go to http://religiondebates.blogspot.com for religious discussions.
- Use the "I" word as much as possible to demonstrate responsibility.
- Limit yourself to using one name per thread to demonstrate responsibility.
- If you think a comment is inappropriate, ask Joe to review it.

0
0 






Vote:
Now there’s a good one. Four day school week! So, should we extend the school year to year round to compensate for the reduced learning. Oh, that’s right — the schools only teach computer skills anyway.
Has anyone really listened or read what students speak and write today? We have lost!